Do Differences in Meershaum Pipes Quality Exist ad/or Matter?

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

New Cigars




PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Status
Not open for further replies.

jpmcwjr

Moderator
Staff member
May 12, 2015
24,570
27,077
Carmel Valley, CA
Of course the answer is yes, and many factors of why this is so have been mentioned.
So, thread will be closed in 48 hours unless there is renewed interest.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TN Jed

PipeIT

Lifer
Nov 14, 2020
4,376
26,150
Hawaii
I sent an email to Altinok, asking them to consider using Eldtrich Resin and hand making custom stems.

Eldritch Products - RawKrafted - https://rawkrafted.com/eldritch-1/

I also will send an email later to @Said.ALTINAY asking the same.

When I look at the pipes from both companies we see the same thing, a lack in quality stems for these pipes.

Tradition is nice, but there is just to extreme an amount of tradition in the Meerschaum industry in regards to the stems. Everywhere you look, the same yellow, orange, red/orange looking stems, extremely generic.

What’s really odd, is that we see Altinok and Altinay making some very nice looking pipes, but with no taste in stem design.

It’s like being a designer with bad or limited taste(s).

I’ve been told Eldtrich doesn’t oxidize, or no where near what traditional vulcanite/ebonite do, or cumberland.

With the vast array of colors in Eldtrich, it only makes sense that if you’re going to offer really nice expensive pipes, they should be made with quality stems.

Now we all know the typical Castello I hate their acrylic stems conversations that go on around here, some like them, some don’t.

So the point being, is a carver like Said going to keep sticking to traditional meerschaum yellow, orange orange/red and balck stems, or will he consider and start offering more?

I guess if he wants to be in the same boat has Castello, acrylic only, so be it, by why limit yourself.

Offering Eldtrich Resin stems in various colors is not going to hurt business, unless you make some pipes in terrible colors, otherwise it’s going to make business better, and those who want better than acrylic, this will certainly open the doors wider with these smokers. :)

Imagine this pipe with a nice handmade Eldtrich resin stem in various colors. 👍

E8503179-8DAD-49F0-AE85-222BAB5E20F3.jpeg

P.S. I’m not dismissing those that want black, great, let’s also get handmade black vulcanite and red cumberland too.. ;)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Browny and lelik

Swiss Army Knife

Can't Leave
Jul 12, 2021
406
1,197
North Carolina
With IMP's jump to a range of around $315 to $355 would you meer veterans still recommend them as value for money? Or would it be better to just custom order or alternatives like Altinay at this point?
 

Chasing Embers

Captain of the Black Frigate
Nov 12, 2014
43,252
108,356
With IMP's jump to a range of around $315 to $355 would you meer veterans still recommend them as value for money? Or would it be better to just custom order or alternatives like Altinay at this point?
Looks like Altinay has gone up as well. They've all gone beyond what I'm willing to justify to pay so I'd just say go with what you like. I've found some sub $100 no name estates that have become my favorites.
 

condorlover1

Lifer
Dec 22, 2013
7,995
26,612
New York
Who were the big names back then? I noticed that you don't ever mention it.
Funny you ask that question. In the utilitarian end of the market that I inhabit you come across a few with addresses in Paris and Berlin. Strangely enough 'Ecume' was not a brand but meant 'Bubbles' in French which is maybe why meerschaum was also known as fossilized sea foam. As far as I can see by the late 1890s various pipe wholesalers in London purchased the meerschaums finished and then put a label in the case with their name on it but I doubt it was carved in their workshop. You also get that feel from surviving catalogues as well. That being said I do have several BBB meerschaum 'cutty' pipes in fitted cases but I have no idea if they were churned out from BBB's workshops. I have a Dunhill style meerschaum 'cutty' that is much the same as the case and style look from the handiwork of any number of the Parisian carvers so who really knows the answer. If you are really interested I can take pictures of any number of case imprints with names and addresses for you to look at and research. Interestingly before the First World War trade was very much international so French, Austria-Hungary and Germany were centers for these types of pipe manufacture as was New York in the U.S with a lot of the carvers being Jewish. Once the world disappeared up its own arse in 1918/19 and the era of free trade vanished so did the numbers of these pipes as you just don't see the numbers after WW1. I would suggest that the increase in cigarette consumption probably didn't help with the support of large numbers of artisan carvers as I would assume the market for cigarette holders was pretty limited.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: TN Jed and PipeIT

didimauw

Moderator
Staff member
Jul 28, 2013
9,895
31,631
34
Burlington WI
Funny you ask that question. In the utilitarian end of the market that I inhabit you come across a few with addresses in Paris and Berlin. Strangely enough 'Ecume' was not a brand but meant 'Bubbles' in French which is maybe why meerschaum was also known as fossilized sea foam. As far as I can see by the late 1890s various pipe wholesalers in London purchased the meerschaums finished and then put a label in the case with their name on it but I doubt it was carved in their workshop. You also get that feel from surviving catalogues as well. That being said I do have several BBB meerschaum 'cutty' pipes in fitted cases but I have no idea if they were churned out from BBB's workshops. I have a Dunhill style meerschaum 'cutty' that is much the same as the case and style look from the handiwork of any number of the Parisian carvers so who really knows the answer. If you are really interested I can take pictures of any number of case imprints with names and addresses for you to look at and research. Interestingly before the First World War trade was very much international so French, Austria-Hungary and Germany were centers for these types of pipe manufacture as was New York in the U.S with a lot of the carvers being Jewish. Once the world disappeared up its own arse in 1918/19 and the era of free trade vanished so did the numbers of these pipes as you just don't see the numbers after WW1. I would suggest that the increase in cigarette consumption probably didn't help with the support of large numbers of artisan carvers as I would assume the market for cigarette holders was pretty limited.
That was possibly the most words used for the term "I don't know".

Hahaha and unfortunately this is what I expected going into this question.

I need to find one in this style, that hasn't been in someone's mouth yet. I haven't been able to find any new cutty's these days.
 

condorlover1

Lifer
Dec 22, 2013
7,995
26,612
New York
@didimauw You can buy new meerschaum 'cutty' pipes - there are many on Ebay and I think Meerschaum Depot has a glut of that style. That was rather lengthy way of saying 'beggared if I know'. You should ask me 'How are you today?' and see how long that answer runs! rotf
 

bullet08

Lifer
Nov 26, 2018
8,932
37,915
RTP, NC. USA
What was the saying? If two things are different, one has to be better? I put it this way. If two things are different, they are different. That almost sounded like that woman on the TV!
 

Briar Lee

Lifer
Sep 4, 2021
4,765
13,789
Humansville Missouri
For centuries the ultimate luxury in tobacco smoking pipes has been a high quality, high grade, expertly carved meerschaum pipe from Turkey.

The only place today all high grade meerschaum is mined is a small area in Central Turkey


There are five categories or qualities) of meerschaum with 12 further quality grades in those.

Your best protection is buying a famous name carver’s work from an established seller.
 

Chasing Embers

Captain of the Black Frigate
Nov 12, 2014
43,252
108,356
Your best protection is buying a famous name carver’s work from an established seller.
That can be a crap shoot. A few smokers including myself have reported terrible draw on Baki's pipes yet some of the no names have been my best pipes. There have been several complaints about the comfort of stems from IMP, Altinay, and others but I find no issue with them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PipeIT

Briar Lee

Lifer
Sep 4, 2021
4,765
13,789
Humansville Missouri
That can be a crap shoot. A few smokers including myself have reported terrible draw on Baki's pipes yet some of the no names have been my best pipes. There have been several complaints about the comfort of stems from IMP, Altinay, and others but I find no issue with them.
All I really know about meerschaums came from standing in a little slot in the wall pipe shop in Springfield Missouri watching the owner (with help from his son) sell unbelievable numbers of high grade, expensive meerschaum pipes to the matrons of the beauty shop next door.

However long it took my mother or wife to get their hair done was my time in his shop.

He had examples of all five grades and 12 qualities of meerschaum and those ladies loved the lesson.:)

He had to be a lost twin brother of Charlie Rich.:)


The best way I learned how to get a good meerschaum was be standing there when my Mama or wife came over after they had their hair done.

I had to talk them out of buying them, sometimes. Seriously, he was that good at it.

He was the best meerschaum pipe sales agent on this planet at the time, say about thirty some years ago.
 

PipeIT

Lifer
Nov 14, 2020
4,376
26,150
Hawaii
A member here a few years back posted this. @Said.ALTINAY if you read this please share with us your thoughts?

1. If there is a way to Grade as suggested below, it would be greatly appreciated Said if you listed this for your pipes.

2. Light as feather is mentioned below, well I certainly see Meerschaum pipes weighing as much as briar. hmm 🤔

———————————-

Meerschaum Grading:
In Turkey, there is a grading system (1 thru 10) with grade 1 being the best. Color, purity, and weight matter in the grading. Most meerschaum has stone mixed in it. It is just a fact of nature. The less stone content, the higher grading.

Color:
The more pure white color the block is, the higher grading.

Purity:
Here is where you really have to look. There is a condition called flecking. Flecking is a flake looking appearance in the surface of the meerschaum. The surface itself is smoothe as it can be. But as the pipe "colors" you will see a checker board effect appear. The coloring will be mixed and not a smoothe even browning.

Weight:
High quality meerschaum is light as a feather! You just have to get your hands on some to get the idea.

This is mentioned on a SPC article;

Pound for pound, meerschaum is more lightweight than briar, so for those who prefer larger tobacco chambers, a meerschaum pipe will tend to be lighter and more comfortably clenched than one of briar of the same dimensions.

P.S. I see a lot of meerschaum pipes of the same dimensions as briar, just as heavy... :(
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.