But why would they think that keeping them clean, would make it color faster? It makes no sense in my mind.
You’re going on the assumption that the goal is to get the Meerschaum to colour faster—one could contend that the goal might be to
keep the pipes clean for
purer taste, and that colouring is just a by-product and possibly unwanted quality of the inability to do so.
I imagine there must’ve been smokers that wanted clean white pipes that offered pure taste and stayed white, and that people just smoked (without a thought of developing colour as a goal).
There’s a part of me that wouldn’t mind if my Meerschaum pipes stayed white. But, through use, it does happen to colour, even with regular cleaning—they’re porous and it’s bound to happen.