Having looked on the internet to a question I have, I want to hear from those here that are “learned veterans” ie experienced and have solid information based on that experience. What is meant by saying “smoking your pipe hot”? Are you talking about how warm the outside of the bowl gets? Are you talking about how hot the tobacco smoke you take in is? I also understand some types of tobacco can get a pipe hot when a) a pipe has thinner bowl b) a particular tobacco has a tendency to smoke hot etc. I would like to understand what is meant when someone talks about (and I usually see a "don't" in front of: “smoking a pipe hot”. Thanks in advance.
Going with the statement "there is no such thing as a dumb question" ...
- Thread starter Gavrin
- Start date
SmokingPipes.com Updates
Watch for Updates Twice a Week
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
Site Sponsors
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
"Too hot" could mean either the bowl is hot to the touch or the smoke stream is hot.
A bowl with thinner walls will likely feel hotter and tobacco which is too wet, too dry, packed incorrectly or puffed too hard will generate more heat.
Tobacco which is too dry will burn too rapidly and tend to give less flavor. Too wet, and steam will result which is considerably hotter than just tobacco smoke.
A bowl with thinner walls will likely feel hotter and tobacco which is too wet, too dry, packed incorrectly or puffed too hard will generate more heat.
Tobacco which is too dry will burn too rapidly and tend to give less flavor. Too wet, and steam will result which is considerably hotter than just tobacco smoke.
That's one of those subjective to the individual things. The drier the better flavor for me. Typically freshly bone dry.
If you get yourself a clay pipe it will teach you just how much you can slow down in order to keep a pipe wall cool...applying the same cadence back to a briar/cob/meer makes for a nice smoke, the opposite of a 'hot pipe'.
It's something like when you want to eat a steak, you want it juicy or charred. It's like when you cook, you try not to burn the food and put it on the plate with all its juice.
@mortonbriar When I got my first clay pipe I thought it might go out; that's the reason for puffing like a steam train in my videos!
But on a still day I was surprised how long I can make a tightly packed clay pipe last. My best time is 45min; I usually get around 15min or less...
@Gavrin there is no such thing as a stupid question. The forum exists for just that purpose.
Happy puffing.
Happy puffing.
If the bowl is hot, your mouth is going to be hot. This is a good indication to slow down on the puffing. You want the essence of the smoke, not the fire. You don't really want that much smoke, but the essence of the smoke. Smoking a dry tobacco at a slow to moderate speed with provide taste, which is what you are after.
Smoking a pipe too hot means the tobacco is receiving too much air and burning too quickly- the result being the actual heat in the chamber is too high. Regulate the air supply by slowing down how often and how strong you puff the pipe. A hot pipe can burn the actual briar and that is a bad thing. You may either burnout the pipe or start burning the inside of the chamber creating an uneven chamber. The flavors of the tobacco will also be negatively impacted as well. As others have said, drying out your tobacco right before you put it in the chamber can improve both the tobacco staying lit without the need to puff so hard as well as improving the flavor of the tobacco by making it more pronounced. Also, stay away from strong drafts. I have found that a high pressured wind can overheat a pipe as well.
I think that clay pipes are a great idea for beginners. If you can get to where you smoke a clay pipe slow enough, you'll definitely be able to slow down enough to enjoy a briar.
I definitely do not enjoy smoking fast.
It's also important to remember that if it gets too hot either to touch or the smoke : stop! Rest till it's cool. Then restart.
Also if tobacco is too wet there will be more steam In the smoke. It may not be hotter but the heat transfer from steam is Huge compared to dry smoke. It will burn you
Also if tobacco is too wet there will be more steam In the smoke. It may not be hotter but the heat transfer from steam is Huge compared to dry smoke. It will burn you
Smoking a pipe “hot” is simply exactly what it sounds like. The pipe is getting hot to the touch while being smoked.
99.999999999 % of the time that’s caused by operator error.
Occasionally it’s the result of smokers who are addicted to producing great clouds of smoke and who puff like freight trains, destroying their pipes. That’s their style and they’re sticking with it.
99.999999999 % of the time that’s caused by operator error.
Occasionally it’s the result of smokers who are addicted to producing great clouds of smoke and who puff like freight trains, destroying their pipes. That’s their style and they’re sticking with it.
The above posts answer the question. Usually, a hot pipe is caused by a person who puffs assiduously and heats up the ember to fireplace heat producing clouds of smoke, in clearly bad technique. Thin bowl walls sometimes cause heat to the touch in some pipes even when smoked very gently, but I have noticed than some thin-walled pipes, like the Kaywoodie Saxon, hardly get warm when smoked properly. Clay pipes confuse the issue a little because even when smoked with the gentlest sipping, the bowl usually heats up too hot to hold, so clay pipes are handled by the shank/stem; you just don't hold the bowl. Cadence matters. Don't even sip too often, just enough to keep the ember going, to get the best flavor out of any blend.
We’ve all thought some questions were dumb, and it prohibited us from asking…this is a mistake. Sometimes it’s best to throw yourself at the mercy of the court & get it over with…that’s what I did. ?
When I started, my first 6 months of smoking was almost assuredly ?. I did everything wrong. Occasionally, I’d get a good smoking experience, but I’m sure that it was the gift of Providence.
Just when I was thinking about giving it up…I began seeking advice & listening to folks that were decades more experienced than I was. Those “masters”were, and still are so very generous with their advice And,I’m so very grateful to those that have helped me learn & most importantly enjoy.
Smoking a pipe gives me such joy & rounds out my days. I wear it with pride, that with the help of all of you, especially during these tough/interesting times…I am a pipe smoker & ? lover.
God bless you all & this forum. ?
️
When I started, my first 6 months of smoking was almost assuredly ?. I did everything wrong. Occasionally, I’d get a good smoking experience, but I’m sure that it was the gift of Providence.
Just when I was thinking about giving it up…I began seeking advice & listening to folks that were decades more experienced than I was. Those “masters”were, and still are so very generous with their advice And,I’m so very grateful to those that have helped me learn & most importantly enjoy.
Smoking a pipe gives me such joy & rounds out my days. I wear it with pride, that with the help of all of you, especially during these tough/interesting times…I am a pipe smoker & ? lover.
God bless you all & this forum. ?
️
@cosmicfolklore Same here, I only smoked too fast because I thought it might go out
So what if your pipe goes out? Are the piping Nazi's going to come and confiscate your pipes and tobaccos and inter you? Will groups of women look at you with amused scorn and whisper unflattering remarks about your manhood to each other?
If your pipe goes out, relight the thing. Simple. Some blends do not burn as readily as others and require a relight or two.
People have their theories on how to best smoke a pipe. I know what works best for me through years of trial and error. That may not work best for someone else.
Sable, I don't understand the message. Are you sure it was addressed to me? ?
Not necessarily. But...have groups of women looked upon you with amused scorn?