Thanks for all the great suggestions. I've tried (and enjoyed!) a great many of them. Going to get some CroMag Aquitanes, which I remember liking quite a bit. The Gran Habano #5 was a cigar I really enjoyed as a newer smoker, but haven't had one in years. Along with the JdN Antano and Oliva G, it was one of the first cigars that convinced me there was something to the whole cigar thing. Might grab me a 5 pack.
Would love to try a Partagas Presidente, as they've been on my list for quite a while. Bolivar #3 will also get added to my list as burleyboy isn't the first I've heard to sing their praises. Good call on the RyJ PC. A lot of the non-churchill line Romeos are stout little bastards. I am super curious about the Club Kings and (Partagas) Capitols since they're finally coming out. If anyone tries either, let me know what you think.
The Litto Gomez are harder to find than Opus right now in my neck of the woods, but will keep my eye out. I had one a few years ago and liked it quite a bit.
May re-visit the 601 Blue label. I remember the Green being pretty stout and La Bomba used to be too much for me, so it might be perfect to try again as well.
Thanks again!