Was it Captain Black (White)?

[PuffyPines]

Hey everyone!
I started smoking a pipe years ago when I was probably around 18 years old. My grandfather always had a pipe with him, and I absolutely loved the smell. When I first started smoking, I believe I was smoking Captain Black "Original" in the white pouch...but now it seems to have changed quite a bit?

I remember a "Zesty" sweet flavor that came through onto my tongue. It reminded me of a sweet candy that had a slight citrusy flavor/feeling to it. It made my mouth water like crazy. But when I smoke captain black now, it just seems bland and dull - like a sweet "hot air". Not much flavor. The aroma is still wonderful though. I am wondering if maybe Captain Black changed their mixture? Or was it possibly a different captain black - Royal, Smooth, etc? Or maybe my tastebuds have changed since then? I don't smoke that often - I would say maybe once every week to every other week. There was a point it was everyday there for about a year, but I slowly came down.

Does anyone recommend something similar to the taste I am looking for?

 

[ray47]

Try Lane Limited RLP-6. That and Lane Limited 1Q is what you may be looking for.

 

[kcghost]

It could be that your taste buds have changed over time. It happens to a lot of smokers.

 

[Model 29]

That is how most tobaccos are to me now. The blends that were so flavorful 40 years ago are now pretty bland

 

[RustiePyles CPG]

CB original is the same thing as bulk RLP-6, give that a try. I find RLP-6 to be a bit better than its pouch/tub counterpart, less PG.

 

[yanoJL]

Try Lane Limited RLP-6. That and Lane Limited 1Q is what you may be looking for.

^ this. Or perhaps MacBaren 7 Seas (regular). It is said to be modeled after the Captain Black you remember. And I can say with impunity, it is an aromatic that tastes like it smells (not always the case with aros)

updating via yoast

www.tobaccoreviews.com

 

[romaso]

Try asking your relatives if they remember what your grandpa smoked, you'll want to know just for nostalgic value.

Capt Black White (Lane RLP-6 in bulk) is the same burley and molasses it's always been for the 40 years I've known it. Try Lane 1-Q (the Royal in bulk), it's been the best selling pipe tobacco in the US for decades. It's a burley with carmel and a little apple.

As far as citrus in an OTC blend, try Sir Walter Raleigh Aromatic, if I remember it has an orange liqueur flavoring.

 

[mso489]

I don't know how it matches up with CB of the past, but I second the motion on Sir Walter Raleigh Aromatic which is burley based, with Virginia as a condiment and flavored with three liqueurs.

It's not quite as fancy as the liqueurs make it sound, but I think it is among the best pouch/tub tobaccos.